MMASucka Judging Panel: UFC 143

Let’s face it, we all think we can do the job better than the ones making the huge amounts of coin scoring fights right? Tonight MMASucka presents a trial-run of a new concept, a judging panel with Jeremy Brand, Trevor Deuck & Justin Faux scoring round-by-round beginning with the FX telecast.

Welterweight bout:  Matthew Riddle vs.  Henry Martinez

Round 1:
Jeremy Brand: 10-9 Martinez
Trevor Deuck: 10-9 Martinez
Justin Faux: 10-9 Martinez

Round 2:
Jeremy Brand: 10-9 Martinez
Trevor Deuck: 10-9 Martinez
Justin Faux: 10-9 Martinez

Round 3:
Jeremy Brand: 10-9 Riddle
Trevor Deuck: 10-9 Riddle
Justin Faux: 10-9 Riddle

MMASucka scores: Henry Martinez wins by Unanimous Decision (29-28, 29-28, 29-28)
Official NSAC scores: Matt Riddle wins by Split Decision (29-28,29-28,29-29)

Welterweight bout:  Matt Brown vs.  Chris Cope

Round 1:
Jeremy Brand: 10-9 Cope
Trevor Deuck: 10-9 Cope
Justin Faux: 10-9 Brown

— Matt Brown finished Chris Cope in the second round.

Bantamweight bout:  Alex Caceres vs.  Edwin Figueroa

Round 1:
Jeremy Brand: 10-9 Caceras
Trevor Deuck: 10-9 Caceras
Justin Faux: 10-10 draw

Round 2:
Jeremy Brand: 9-8 Figueroa
Trevor Deuck: 9-8 Figueroa
Justin Faux: 9-8 Figueroa

Round 3:
Jeremy Brand: 10-9 Caceras
Trevor Deuck: 10-9 Caceras
Justin Faux: 10-9 Caceras

MMASucka scores: Caceras won by Majority Decision (28-27,28-27,27-27)
NSAC official scores: Figueroa won by Split Decision  (28-27, 28-27, 28-27)

Featherweight bout:  Dustin Poirier vs.  Max Holloway

—  Dustin Poirier submitted Hollaway in the first round.

Middleweight bout:  Ed Herman vs.  Clifford Starks

Round 1:
Jeremy Brand: 10-9 Starks
Trevor Deuck: 10-9 Herman
Justin Faux: 10-9 Herman
Carlin Bardsley: 10-9 Herman

— Herman submitted Starks in the second round

Bantamweight bout:  Renan Barão vs.  Scott Jorgensen

Round 1:
Jeremy Brand: 10-9 Barao
Trevor Deuck: 10-9 Barao
Justin Faux: 10-9 Barao
Carlin Bardsley:  10-9 Barao

Round 2:
Jeremy Brand: 10-9 Barao
Trevor Deuck:  10-9 Barao
Justin Faux: 10-9 Barao
Carlin Bardsley:  10-9 Barao

Round 3:
Jeremy Brand: 10-9 Jorgensen
Trevor Deuck: 10-9 Jorgensen
Justin Faux: 10-9 Barao
Carlin Bardsley:  10-9 Barao

MMASucka scores it: Renan Barao wins by Unanimous Decision (29-28, 29-28, 30-27,30-27)
NSAC scores it: Renan Barao wins by Unanimous Decision (30-27, 30-27, 29-28)

Welterweight bout:  Josh Koscheck vs.  Mike Pierce

Round 1:
Jeremy Brand: 10-9 Pierce
Trevor Deuck: 10-9 Pierce
Justin Faux: 10-9 Koscheck
Carlin Bardsley:  10-9 Koscheck

Round 2:
Jeremy Brand: 10-9 Koscheck
Trevor Deuck: 10-9 Koscheck
Justin Faux: 10-9 Pierce
Carlin Bardsley: 10-9 Pierce  

Round 3:
Jeremy Brand: 10-9 Pierce
Trevor Deuck: 10-9 Pierce
Justin Faux: 10-9 Koscheck
Carlin Bardsley:  10-9 Koscheck

MMASucka scores:  Majority draw (29-28,29-28,29-28,29-28)
NSAC official scores: Josh Koscheck wins by Split Decision (29-28, 29-28, 29-28)

Heavyweight bout: Roy Nelson vs.  Fabricio Werdum

Round 1:
Jeremy Brand: 10-9 Werdum
Trevor Deuck: 10-9 Werdum
Justin Faux: 10-9 Werdum
Carlin Bardsley:  10-9 Werdum

Round 2:
Jeremy Brand: 10-9 Nelson
Trevor Deuck: 10-9 Nelson
Justin Faux: 10-9 Werdum
Carlin Bardsley:  10-9 Werdum 

Round 3:
Jeremy Brand: 10-9 Werdum
Trevor Deuck: 10-9 Werdum
Justin Faux: 10-9 Werdum
Carlin Bardsley:  10-9 Werdum

MMASucka scores: Fabricio Werdum wins by Unanimous Decision (29-28,29-28,30-27,30-27)
Official NSAC score: Fabricio Werdum wins by Unanimous Decision (30–27, 30–27, 30–27)

Interim Welterweight Championship bout:  Nick Diaz vs.  Carlos Condit

Round 1:
Jeremy Brand: 10-9 Condit
Trevor Deuck: 10-9 Diaz
Justin Faux: 10-9 Condit
Carlin Bardsley: 10-9 Condit

Round 2:
Jeremy Brand: 10-9 Condit
Trevor Deuck: 10-9 Diaz
Justin Faux: 10-9 Diaz
Carlin Bardsley:  10-9 Diaz

Round 3:
Jeremy Brand: 10-9 Diaz
Trevor Deuck: 10-9 Condit
Justin Faux: 10-9 Condit
Carlin Bardsley:  10-9 Condit

Round 4:
Jeremy Brand: 10-9 Condit
Trevor Deuck: 10-9 Condit
Justin Faux: 10-9 Condit
Carlin Bardsley:  10-9 Condit

Round 5:
Jeremy Brand: 10-9 Condit
Trevor Deuck: 10-9 Condit
Justin Faux: 10-9 Diaz
Carlin Bardsley: 10-9  Diaz

MMASucka score: Carlos Condit wins by Unanimous Decision (48-47, 48-47, 48-47)
Official NSAC score: Carlos Condit wins by Unanimous Decision (48–47, 49–46, 49–46)